Not a fan at all. Really bitter and burn was horrible. I could keep it lit. It sat in the humidor (69%) with everything else I have. Not sure what the deal was. Didn't even make it through the first third before tossing.
First third of this is very earthy with cedar and a little pepper. Second third has a bitter dark chocolate with pepper flavor. Last third has a leather with heavier pepper still very earthy with an almost a hint of hay. Pleasant smoke as most Caldwell cigars are.